By Aurélia Etienne & Nicolás Bordier

‘Roads of Development’ is, before anything, the fulfilment of a dream, the making of a documentary, and the promotion of a reflection over a topic that has mattered to us for some many years: the inequities between North and South, and the policies and projects that try to reduce them.
We began working in different development programmes full of good intentions, because for us it was a job that made much sense. After various NGO experiences, our outlook about the approaches used by assistance programmes evolved, as did our position about them.
Many times we questioned the legitimacy of our presence as foreigners in a culture that wasn’t ours; applying development models that sometimes were not very participatory, and pretending to give advice to farmers who, generations beforehand, had acquired a wisdom that wasn’t even in books. The reality of the programmes on the terrain was far much different then we could have imagined before participating in them.
We confirmed that the majority of these projects worked “well and bad” while NGOs and public institutions were present. However, when the project ended, the only thing that lasted were the vestiges of the infrastructures built, and of the associations created the only thing that remained was their name on paper. Nevertheless, the experience gained was there.
We then asked ourselves why the majority of the development programmes and projects did not allow the most deprived populations to progress, thus improving their livelihoods. We tried to understand this through the documentary “Roads of Development”.
This documentary was filmed in the Callejon de Huaylas in 2007. It proposes a reflection about the success and failure factors for projects with the aim of reducing poverty and hunger, based on the review of 2 implemented projects differentiating in scope, impact, and approach.
The first one is the Cordillera Negra Programme, the biggest in scope ever implemented in the Callejon de Huaylas (24 million Euros, 24 500 families to be benefited), executed from 1997 to 2003, but, in the present, the only thing that remains are some abandoned infrastructures and sometimes the resentment of the communities. The second project is Agua para Siempre (Everlasting Water), implemented with a smaller budget (US$ 40 000), which still continues to function today, 6 years after the end of the project.
We recorded 50 hours of film and registered the testimonials of 23 different development actors: farmers, engineers, technicians, and sociologists. After the editing process, we had 10 testimonials for a documentary of 42 minutes. “Roads of Development” will be available on DVD from January 2008 onwards, and viewings will be carried out in Huaraz and Lima accompanied by debates.

This film has been an exciting adventure, it is extremely rich in the knowledge gained from many perspectives that has enriched our reflection about the development process. Although today we have now some answers to our initial question, each project is a case apart.
None withstanding, some common reasons of why projects fail can be mentioned:

‘Roads of Development’ is, before anything, the fulfilment of a dream, the making of a documentary, and the promotion of a reflection over a topic that has mattered to us for some many years: the inequities between North and South, and the policies and projects that try to reduce them.
We began working in different development programmes full of good intentions, because for us it was a job that made much sense. After various NGO experiences, our outlook about the approaches used by assistance programmes evolved, as did our position about them.
Many times we questioned the legitimacy of our presence as foreigners in a culture that wasn’t ours; applying development models that sometimes were not very participatory, and pretending to give advice to farmers who, generations beforehand, had acquired a wisdom that wasn’t even in books. The reality of the programmes on the terrain was far much different then we could have imagined before participating in them.
We confirmed that the majority of these projects worked “well and bad” while NGOs and public institutions were present. However, when the project ended, the only thing that lasted were the vestiges of the infrastructures built, and of the associations created the only thing that remained was their name on paper. Nevertheless, the experience gained was there.
We then asked ourselves why the majority of the development programmes and projects did not allow the most deprived populations to progress, thus improving their livelihoods. We tried to understand this through the documentary “Roads of Development”.
This documentary was filmed in the Callejon de Huaylas in 2007. It proposes a reflection about the success and failure factors for projects with the aim of reducing poverty and hunger, based on the review of 2 implemented projects differentiating in scope, impact, and approach.
The first one is the Cordillera Negra Programme, the biggest in scope ever implemented in the Callejon de Huaylas (24 million Euros, 24 500 families to be benefited), executed from 1997 to 2003, but, in the present, the only thing that remains are some abandoned infrastructures and sometimes the resentment of the communities. The second project is Agua para Siempre (Everlasting Water), implemented with a smaller budget (US$ 40 000), which still continues to function today, 6 years after the end of the project.
We recorded 50 hours of film and registered the testimonials of 23 different development actors: farmers, engineers, technicians, and sociologists. After the editing process, we had 10 testimonials for a documentary of 42 minutes. “Roads of Development” will be available on DVD from January 2008 onwards, and viewings will be carried out in Huaraz and Lima accompanied by debates.

This film has been an exciting adventure, it is extremely rich in the knowledge gained from many perspectives that has enriched our reflection about the development process. Although today we have now some answers to our initial question, each project is a case apart.
None withstanding, some common reasons of why projects fail can be mentioned:
- There is no real encounter between the institutions and the so called beneficiaries, many times each comes from a different culture and living conditions. It takes time to remove prejudices, and understand and change the perceptions that each group has about the other;
- Development projects are often conceived as the “goose that lays the golden eggs”: an opportunity that you should make good use of by every development actor. It is better to take the most out of it while the project is running, because tomorrow will be another day. It is why there exist many productive societies that the only they have about societies is the name because it may be the requisite to get support from the NGOs (to be formally constituted);
- Project staffs are mostly composed of persons that have had access to a formal and superior education: technicians, engineers, etc. A majority of them have a vertical and technical business only approach, and a conviction of having to transmit their knowledge to those who don’t have it, of trying to change their ways of doing, of reorienting their activities looking of an increase in productivity as the main goal, and promoting the export of their goods whatever it takes;
- The financing system of national and international development cooperation explains by itself this collision of interests. Thus, as NGOs need to secure funding for several years, they apply to many Request For Proposals from donors that finance short term projects. Then, they need to formulate complex projects to be executed in a short period of time. Here we have a conflict on project implementation and long lasting results. The time needed for a development process to be completed does not necessarily correspond to the time that a development project lasts, mostly from 1 to 5 years;
- In the same manner, donors don’t fund the initial project appraisal phase; this baseline study allows a better understanding of the socioeconomic and cultural context where the projects will be implemented. What happens is that many projects are born in an office, far away from the area where the project will be implemented, and formulated by a few people whose knowledge about the target populations is minimal and varied. As we know, one of the conditions of the sustainability of projects is the level of participation of the beneficiaries at the start.
We expect, through this film, to create a new awareness for many people about what happens on terrain in the development assistance arena, as well as fostering a discussion about some errors made.
This documentary is a truth and a perspective amongst many others, but through it we try to emphasize the grand human adventure that constitutes each development project, where the encounter between the participating populations and project staff is essential and the opening up to other perceptions of reality with humbleness is crucial.
This documentary is a truth and a perspective amongst many others, but through it we try to emphasize the grand human adventure that constitutes each development project, where the encounter between the participating populations and project staff is essential and the opening up to other perceptions of reality with humbleness is crucial.












No hay comentarios.:
Publicar un comentario